Warning this is a rant
Just after I had been offered a place at university to study for a degree in Politics I was walking in Nairobi city centre with a member of my family when we bumped into a lady who at the time could reasonably claim to be the most powerful woman in Kenya. Well when I say we bumped into her, we bumped into her and her entourage of bodyguard/cronies. After the exchange of pleasantries amongst the wazee attention was focused on me.
“Young man what are you doing with your life”, this powerful woman directed at me.
“I am at university”, I replied.
“What are you studying?”
“Politics” I replied.
” Politics, POLitics, POLITICS???? NO. You must change your course. We need doctors, we need engineers, and we need accountants.”
She then proceeded to lecture me in the middle of Nairobi city centre about my lack of understanding of Kenya’s situation, about my wasted life, she gave what was ironically a very political speech on why I should not do politics. Here was a person who had grown rich in the excess of the dark days of Moi’s regime giving me a lecture on accountability. That in itself steeled my resolve to study politics if nothing else just to find out what she didn’t want me to know.
Fastforward 2 years. This time I am sitting a Christmas lunch for African students organised by a prestigious and powerful international organisation. Each student was assigned a partner from the great and good for the night. The look my hosts face when he learnt I was studying politcs can only be described as horrified. You should be doing medicine, veterinary science, engineering, he told me. Is it to late to change your course?
I can give you countless more examples all with the same central theme. Africa does not need students of politics.
Bollox.
It is now fashionable to lay the blame for Africa’s problems at the feet of Africa’s political leaders. This opinion is justified in more ways than one. Our leaders have let us down again and again. Sometimes you wonder whether they know what they are doing, don’t you? Well what do you expect?
Take Kenya as an example. You take a unique parliamentary system of cabinet government which took the UK centuries to develop and evolve for themselves, mix it with a presidential system of governement which the fathers of America developed in direct opposition to the British model and then thrown in some measures to make the president untouchable thus in a stroke wiping out the whole principle of checks and balances and impose it on a young African democracy, you can not seriously expect the thing to work. And it didn’t and it doesn’t. Those of us who studied politics can hardly understand just how the system is meant to work. So what chance do you amateurs have?
Africa needs student of politics, millions of them. I’ll let John Adams explain
I must study politics and war that my sons may have liberty to study mathematics and philosophy. My sons ought to study mathematics and philosophy, geography, natural history, naval architecture, navigation, commerce and agriculture in order to give their children a right to study painting, poetry, music, architecture, statuary, tapestry, and porcelain.
John Adams
Without a political base, with out a civic base, without governance, without the people running the country knowing how to run the country we will never move forward. It is as simple as that. You can have the best LSE educated economists at the helm which we do, you can have the Oxbridge educated lawyers being driven in cars with ministerial flags, which we do but without the political scientist to examine, probe, devise a system of governance you will end up with chaos.
But isn’t the UK government full of lawyers. Si Tony Blair is a lawyer?
Yes but in the UK everyone knows how the system works. It has been working for centuries. Go back to the beginning when they were making drastic changes to the constitution, when political ideologies were being formed and you will find great thinkers who devoted their whole lives to politics.
In Kenya politicians do not even know what they stand for leave alone what the want to impose on the country. At the last election a group of Social Democratic Party candidates were asked which of their policies where social democratic in nature. Their response, and I quote directly, “argh we just took this name because political parties have such names.” Clowns. Do they understand that by calling themselves Social Democratic they are casting their lot with a movement over 100 years old? That it actually means something? What about the Liberal Party of Kenya? Do they believe in proportional representation? In internationalism? Do they understand that Liberalism argues that the F-P-T-P system of elections, which we use in Kenya, is flawed? Do they care? And what about our good friends the Democratic Party?
How about our regional organisations? Is there any surprise that the OAU failed? I mean that constitution was probably written by doctors and then you have a bunch of chemical engineers, lawyers, economists to try and put it into practice. Where were the political diplomats? The professional negotiators, the professional civil service, the political administrators of the continent if you like? (I can feel a post on the amateurisation of politics coming along!)
Without us, who study peace and war, who study man and his thoughts, who study political systems, who study governance, who learn how to run countries, the political technocrats, the professional government administrators, without us my friend everything will go to the dogs. Want proof, look around Africa.
Yes I know this sounds like I am trying to justify my life.
Yes I know we have brilliant political minds in Kenya even in SDP, LPK and DP.
Rant over. Let’s all go look at a pictures of a cute giraffe! Ahhhhh!










9 comments
Comments feed for this article
April 13, 2005 at 5:00 pm
githush
What are you studying? Politics and what do u want to do with that? These are the questions I have to deal with whenever I inform someone that I am studying politics. This is compounded by the fact that I switched majors, I was first studying Aerospace engineering, but the good Lord put it in my heart to change my major to siasa. My family accepted my change (though I had to provide them with a thick dossier on why I should study politics), but I occassionaly get the “what are you doing with your life?” your were so good in the sciences, why don’t u do sth in that field? But I have stuck to my guns and hope to fanya a MA and Phd in the field.
I agree with you whole heartedly on the issue of parties. I often ask myself, what is the difference between LDP, NAK, DP, SDP and KANU? what do these parties stand for? what do they believe in? and when one compares them with the Democrats, republicans, labour, Conservatives, SPD, CDU, BJP, Congress etc. etc. we see that Kenyan political parties are vacous, they have no concrete ideal that hold them together and that is why u see people like my former MP Nyanja jumping from one party to another before elections (5 times in 1997). Parties are nothing more than extensions of the personalities that control them.
I am sorry this comment is so long, lakini it is very rare to hear, or read comments similar to the above. Which I share completely.
April 13, 2005 at 10:06 pm
githush
Found this interesting article by bwana William Ruot on this very issue.
http://www.eastandard.net/hm_news/news.php?articleid=17922
April 14, 2005 at 12:19 am
cirdan
here’s to your sons studying philosophy.
April 15, 2005 at 5:16 pm
Memoire
I really commend you on this post; it’s a shame that Kenyans still hold onto the mentality that only certain degrees are “valuable.” I hope that the present generation will challenge that - but the problem is that the 8-4-4 system is such that students are programmed into such mindsets. We need graduates in every subject, even kina languages and arts are neglected/ looked down upon.
April 15, 2005 at 5:36 pm
Kishawi
I just stumbled on to your site for the first time today and it’s like a huge breath of fresh air. Politics rocks indeed and I commend you on challenging expectation and pursuing something that is in desperate need of revolution. People back home (Kenya) say go study medicine, go study law, go study engineering and what do most who listen go on and do? Practice it in the country they learned it! So while it may be argued that they still help Kenya out by bringing money in—this is temporary relief as the fundamental issues are not being addressed. But I will not continue to rant about brain drain…
Your quote by John Adams was profoundly appropriate. I myself dismissed all the ‘polite suggestions’ that I use my academic talents to pursue medicine, law, engineering etc. because frankly, the passion wasn’t there. So I went on to study communication design and while I do love the arts tremendously and recognise their potential in facilitating social development and social change…something was amiss for me. How is it that I know and understand more about Western history, culture and society than I do my own? And how is this still being propagated by education systems back home? In the quest to decolonise my mind and to hopefully impress upon others the need to do the same, I realise that I first must deal with some fundamental things that will better inform my participation in the arts. So my next degree will be in African Studies. And as I await the questions of “Why study that? You’re African?!”, finding sites like these continues to inspire, excite and stimulate me and, in moments of doubt (they are few and far between!) remind me to hold to my convictions.
April 17, 2005 at 11:23 pm
mentalacrobatics
I see i have company! Thanks for all your comments! We should set up a political talking shop or something!
April 18, 2005 at 5:22 am
Harry
I congratulate you on your decision to study politics. I also study politics, for many of the same reasons as you.
I admire you, for wishing to become an educated leader to make something for the future of your country. good luck, friend.
December 9, 2005 at 3:47 am
bimo
Its probably too late to make a comment on this topic, but i will anyway. My friend I commend you for studying politics for a better future for everyone’s well being.
Many of us nowadays dont reason like that or should I say dont really give a damn!!! Keep up the good work.
December 9, 2005 at 8:48 am
Mentalacrobatics
Thank you for your comments! Good luck with your studies Harry and Bimo karibu, it is never too late to comment.