Earlier this year the “Artur brothers”, foreign mercenaries brought into Kenya to create chaos, allegedly pulled out guns at Jomo Kenyatta International Airport and threatened members of the public and members of the security services before speeding of in their cars. When witness at the commission set up to investigate the event differed on whether or not guns were pulled, the commission asked for tapes from the CCTV cameras, which were perfectly positioned to record the events. The commission was informed that apparently the cameras were not working that day.
Second example, John Githongo, the former Permanent Secretary in charge of Governance and Ethics who was forced to flee Kenya due to his investigations into corruption, meets with officials from the Kenya Anti Corruption Commission at the Kenyan embassy in London to present a dossier containing evidence of corruption by senior members of Kibaki’s government. To avoid confusion in the future about what was said and what wasn’t said during the meeting it is agreed that the anti corruption officials will take an audio recording of the proceedings and to that effect the anti corruption officials brought the necessary equipment to the meeting. Months later after Martha Karua, Minister for Justice, accused Githongo of, “not co-operating with the investigators” Githongo asked for the audio recordings to be made public only to be told by Aaron Ringera, the head of the Kenyan Anti Corruption Commission, that the recording equipment had failed.
Thirdly, on Sunday we learnt that somehow thugs managed to break into the heavily guarded Times Tower in Nairobi, managed to get to the 14th floor which is occupied by the section of the Kenya Revenue Authority which holds sensitive tax records and managed to steal a large number of computers with vital data, all this without any struggle and police even believe the perpetrators may have had keys to the building. The icing on the cake comes when the KRA informs us that most probably the stolen data was not backed up.
From these three examples we learn that the authorities can not record video, fail to record audio and do not back up vital computer records. Either that or someone somewhere is taking us for fools.
JKIA has applied for “Category One” status. This would enable airlines to fly direct to the United States from Kenya. The key component to getting Category One status is security. Now the Kenyan airport authorities want us to believe that during the biggest security breech EVER at a Kenyan airport the CCTV cameras were not working. Yeah right.
The Kenyan Anti Corruption Commission and the parliamentary Public Accounts Committee travel all the way to London with the sole purpose of interviewing Githongo to hear his evidence against the perpetrators of corruption in Kenya, someone of them senior political figures. Are we seriously meant to believe that on that day of all days, in that meeting of all meetings, that the audio equipment failed? And no one noticed it had failed on the day so they could record another session? They only “discovered” it had failed when they got back to Kenya? The equipment used by the KACC was same as used by the parliamentary Public Accounts Committee where it worked flawlessly. Did they not test the equipment? Did they not check to see if it had recorded on the day? It just failed? Yeah right.
And how can an organisation as through and determined as the KRA have the audacity to tell us that vital tax records that were held on computers which just happened to be stolen (from the 14th floor - no hit, grab and run mission this) just happened not to be backed up? The KRA wants us to believe that they have worse data management skills than any high school student in the world who all know you must keep at least two copies of vital documents? Yeah right!
Whatever you do, do not hire this government to record your wedding. You’d be lucky if they managed to capture anything at all.










6 comments
Comments feed for this article
Trackback link
http://www.mentalacrobatics.com/think/archives/2006/09/taken_for_a_ride.php/trackback
September 26, 2006 at 2:36 pm
bankelele
With regard to KRA, that’s been happening a lot in the last few months. People have raided government offices (ECK, Min of Energy) and private companies, only to make off with the hard drives of specific computers. There’s obviously some insider knowledge beforehand but its’ something that IT departments will have to wake up and be ready to cope with e.g off-site servers and back-ups.
As for CCTV tapes, they are rarely stored, many don’t even record or monitor since if nothing happens, the bank will just over-write the tape in a few days.
September 26, 2006 at 2:42 pm
uaridi
HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO YOU, Mentalacrobatics. Happy Birthday to the young man who has the most polite and gentle voice it has been my joy to hear.
May you be blessed and have many, many more birthdays
September 26, 2006 at 4:14 pm
sammie
Hi there Mental. Quite a lot you had to say on this your day.
If it were Alfred responding to your allegations, this would be his speech:
We at The Government (i’ll continue, like all of us, to alienate myself from it and politely refer to it by its company name) do not take exceptions when it comes to matters of security.
We like to appear efficient, we also like to appear classy and we also like to explain every dammn thing!
The stolen data was not actually stolen, but we had a computer hitch.
Our backup systems we cannot discuss because that will be a security breach.
The faulty audio equipment was probably left outside in the London rain as the PAC comittee chased after Githongo, and that is why it did not work.
Lastly i would like to send heaty birthday wishes to you and your loved ones on behalf of The Government
Tuendelee kujivunia kuwa wakenya.
Thank you.
September 26, 2006 at 4:17 pm
sammie
Hearty!
September 26, 2006 at 4:26 pm
african
Machines are only as effective as the people behind them. You can have the best CCTV in the world but if it isnt turned on or the tapes erased it is no good. The human element is always the biggest flaw. But I am disappointed that a whole government and it’s minstries seem to have no idea about backing up important data, a concept any basic IT student is familiar with.
But incompotence is no defence for shady dealings at all!
September 26, 2006 at 4:41 pm
Mimmz
I personally don’t find it shocking that neither of these equipment worked as expected. First and foremost, it takes good governance and money to make sure that cameras are monitored and working efficiently. That having been said, that they weren’t working on the Artur brother’s day is to be expected.
btw, the Artur brothers, guns in airport, having just flown in, that breach is not a JKIA security breach. Anyone in a landing zone should be considered safe having gone through security wherever they boarded at. Of course, unless there is more to this story than it was told and than it has been believed.